Blake2b vs. Keccak (SHA-3): A Comparison

Blake2b and Keccak are both highly secure, modern cryptographic hash functions that emerged as finalists in the NIST SHA-3 competition. While Keccak was ultimately selected as the SHA-3 standard, Blake2b (an evolution of the BLAKE finalist) offers compelling advantages, particularly in software performance. Choosing between them depends on specific application requirements like speed, hardware optimization, or adherence to the official SHA-3 standard.

What is Blake2b?

Blake2b is an optimized version of the BLAKE hash function. Its primary design goal was to achieve extremely high performance, especially on modern 64-bit processors, without compromising security. It often outperforms MD5, SHA-1, SHA-2, and even SHA-3 in software implementations. Blake2b offers variable output sizes (up to 512 bits) and features like optional keying, making it a versatile and widely adopted choice for scenarios where hashing speed is critical, such as file integrity verification or data deduplication.

What is Keccak (SHA-3)?

Keccak is the algorithm chosen by NIST as the SHA-3 standard (FIPS 202). It features a novel "sponge construction" which differs significantly from the Merkle–Damgård structure used in SHA-1 and SHA-2. This different structure provides strong resistance against attacks applicable to older standards, like length extension attacks. Keccak (in its SHA-3 variants like SHA3-256, SHA3-512, SHAKE128, SHAKE256, etc.) offers a high security margin and is often well-optimized for hardware implementations.

Key Differences & Considerations

FeatureBlake2bKeccak (SHA-3 variants)
SHA-3 Competition StatusFinalist (Blake family)Winner (Selected as SHA-3 standard)
Internal StructureHAIFA construction (similar to Merkle-Damgård but enhanced)Sponge Construction
Primary StrengthSoftware Speed & EfficiencyHigh Security Margin, Hardware Efficiency, Standardization
Software Performance (Typical)Generally FasterGenerally Slower (than Blake2b)
Hardware Performance (Typical)GoodOften Excellent (design facilitates efficient hardware)
Resistance to Length ExtensionResistant (Improved over SHA-2)Resistant (by nature of sponge construction)
Use CasesFast integrity checks, file hashing, anywhere speed is paramountStandardized protocols, systems requiring official SHA-3 compliance, hardware security modules

The choice often comes down to priorities. If maximum hashing speed in software is the primary concern and adherence to the SHA-3 standard isn't strictly necessary, Blake2b is a very strong contender. If compatibility with the NIST standard, potential hardware acceleration benefits, or the robust theoretical security margin of the sponge construction are more important, then Keccak (in its SHA-3 variants) is the logical choice.

Checksum Tools

Adler-32
Calculate Adler-32 hash values for data integrity verification.
CRC-16
CRC-16 is primarily used for error detection. Ideal for serial communication protocols, peripheral device communication, automotive systems and storage devices
CRC-24
CRC-24 is commonly used for data integrity verification in various specialized applications, including telecommunications, OpenPGP, and Bluetooth Low Energy protocols.
CRC-32
CRC-32 is widely used for error detection and data integrity verification in various applications, including file transfer protocols and storage systems.
CRC-64
CRC-64 is a 64-bit cyclic redundancy check algorithm used in various applications, including data storage and transmission.
Fletcher-16
Fletcher-16 is a non-cryptographic checksum algorithm designed for error detection, similar to CRCs but often faster and with better detection for some types of errors.
Fletcher-32
Fletcher-32 is a a quick and strong checksum suitable for higher performance embedded systems, real-time OS or middleware & scientific data handling.
Double SHA-256
Generate Double SHA-256 hashes used in Bitcoin and blockchain applications.
MD5
Generate MD5 checksums online for fast and reliable data verification as well as working with legacy systems.
SHA1
Use this free SHA1 generator to compute checksums and ensure data accuracy.
RIPEMD-160
RIPEMD-160 is a cryptographic hash function which is heavily used in Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies
Whirlpool
Easily generate Whirlpool checksums to validate files and detect transmission errors.
SHA224
Create (SHA-2 family) SHA224 checksums instantly to verify file content and ensure data integrity.
SHA256
Widely used algorithm SHA256 checksum calculator to generate hash values for security, networking, storage & data compression
SHA384
Generate SHA384 checksums for secure data verification and digital signatures.
SHA512
Calculate SHA512 hashes to check file consistency and prevent data corruption.
SHA3-224
Online SHA3-224 checksum calculator for accurate and efficient data verification.
SHA3-256
Create SHA3-256 cryptographic hash values.
SHA3-384
Calculate SHA3-384 hash values to verify file integrity and detect data corruption.
SHA3-512
Generate SHA3-512 checksums online for fast and reliable data verification.
SHAKE128
Calculate SHAKE128 hash values to verify file integrity and detect data corruption.
SHAKE256
Generate variable-length hash values with SHAKE256 extendable output function for higher security.
Keccak
Generate Keccak (SHA-3 Variant) hash values used in Ethereum blockchain.
Blake2b
Generate Blake2b hashes used in Siacoin and Verge mining.
Blake2s
BLAKE2s is a fast, secure cryptographic hash function ideal for checksums, data integrity, and file verification. Faster than MD5.
Blake3
BLAKE3 is a fast, secure, and highly parallelizable cryptographic hash function, outperforming SHA-2, SHA-3, and BLAKE2 in speed